Should You Use ZenBusiness or File Your New York LLC Directly with the State?

The short answer

The Articles of Organization are the easy part. The Department of State charges $200 to file them, whether you submit them yourself or a provider submits them for you. Publication is the harder part. After formation, a New York LLC must publish notice that it exists and then file a Certificate of Publication, which costs $50 to file with the Department of State. The Department of State says that if you fail to publish within 120 days, your LLC's authority to do business is suspended. The newspapers set their own charges for the notices, not the state, and those charges vary by county, so no single figure applies.

ZenBusiness's Starter plan costs $0 plus state fees. Pro is $199 a year and Premium is $299 a year. A registered agent is a separate service on every tier. It costs $99 for the first year when you form with ZenBusiness and $199 a year after that. None of these prices replace the state's $200 filing fee, the $50 Certificate of Publication fee, or the newspaper costs.

If you read instructions carefully and want the lowest total cost, filing directly is the stronger choice. If you would rather hand off the preparation and have support available while you form, a service can be worth the money, as long as you know what you are paying for.

New York LLC fees and requirements at a glance

What filing directly with the state involves

When you file yourself, you submit the Articles of Organization to the Department of State and pay the $200 fee. The form is short. The detail people most often get wrong is the county. The Department of State requires the Articles to name a county, and New York City residents need to use the county name rather than the borough name. Manhattan is New York County, Brooklyn is Kings County, Queens is Queens County, the Bronx is Bronx County, and Staten Island is Richmond County. The county you choose also matters later, because publication is handled in the county named in your Articles.

You also do not need to hire anyone to receive legal papers for you. The Articles designate the Secretary of State to accept service of process on the LLC's behalf. A paid registered agent is optional in New York, not a requirement.

The publication requirement and what it costs

Publication is the step that makes New York different from most states, and it is where DIY filers most often slip. The state's own charges are clear: $50 to file the Certificate of Publication once the notices have run. The newspaper charges are not published by the state, because each newspaper sets its own rates and those rates vary by county. The Department of State's formation page explains the publication steps in full, so read it before you pick a county.

The deadline has consequences. The Department of State says that failing to publish within 120 days suspends your LLC's authority to do business. For many founders, this deadline is the real reason to consider paying for help.

If publication help is why you are considering a provider, get ZenBusiness's exact price before you buy. Also ask whether that price includes the newspaper charges and the $50 state fee, or whether those are billed separately.

What ZenBusiness charges, and how it compares

The comparison below is listed alphabetically, not ranked.

The state's costs do not change based on who files. A provider can only charge you for work on top of the state's fees, so the useful question is whether that work is worth it to you.

Filing yourself is the better call if you are forming a simple LLC and are willing to read the Department of State's instructions and track the 120-day publication deadline on your own calendar. You do not need a paid registered agent in New York. You also do not need a paid plan to get an EIN.

ZenBusiness fits a different reader. It suits someone who wants the filing prepared for them, prefers one account for their formation paperwork, and values having support available over saving the service fee. The Starter tier costs nothing beyond state fees, which makes it a low-risk way to hand off the filing itself. The paid tiers renew every year at $199 or $299, and the registered agent renews at $199 after the first year. Budget for the renewals, not just the first-year price.

llcprovidercompare.com earns a commission on some links, including ZenBusiness. That does not change the recommendation above. For many New York filers, the cheapest correct answer is to file directly.

After you form: EIN and ownership reporting

The IRS says to form the entity with the state first and then apply for an EIN. The EIN is free directly from the IRS, and the IRS warns against paying a third party for one.

On ownership reporting, FinCEN states that companies formed in the United States are exempt from federal beneficial ownership information reporting. New York's LLC Transparency Act applies only to LLCs formed under the law of a foreign country, so a US-formed LLC is not required to file under it.

FAQ